Organic Chemistry Homework Help: Reaction Mechanisms

Home / general / Organic Chemistry Homework Help: Reaction Mechanisms
Organic chemistry homework help: a method for reaction mechanisms

Organic chemistry homework help usually starts with the same complaint: “I can follow the mechanism in lecture, but I cannot draw one myself.” The fix is to stop treating mechanisms as pictures to memorise and start treating them as a story about electrons. This guide gives you a five-step method for arrow pushing, a way to reason about SN1, SN2, E1 and E2, three worked examples and the errors that cost the most marks.

What does a mechanism actually show?

A reaction mechanism shows how electrons move as bonds break and form. Curved arrows are the notation. Each arrow starts where a pair of electrons is, either a lone pair or a bond, and points to where that pair ends up, either a new bond or an atom that takes the pair as a lone pair. Two ideas drive almost everything:

  • Nucleophile: an electron-rich species (often with a lone pair or a negative charge) that donates a pair of electrons to form a bond.
  • Electrophile: an electron-poor species (often a carbon with a partial positive charge, such as the carbon of a carbonyl or a carbon attached to a halogen) that accepts that pair.

Almost every step is “a nucleophile attacks an electrophile”, sometimes with a leaving group departing at the same time.

What is the five-step method?

  1. Label the nucleophile and the electrophile. Look at charges, lone pairs and polar bonds. Ask which species has electrons to give and which has a place to put them.
  2. Find the leaving group, if there is one. Halides, water and sulfonates leave well because they are stable on their own.
  3. Draw the arrows from the electron source to the electron sink. The tail sits on the lone pair or bond. The head points to the atom or bond that receives the pair. Never start an arrow on an atom nucleus.
  4. Redraw the structure after each step. Update bonds, lone pairs and formal charges. Do not combine steps unless your course does.
  5. Check the result. Every atom should have a sensible octet (hydrogen has two electrons), and the total charge should be the same before and after.

How do you choose between SN1, SN2, E1 and E2?

When an alkyl halide meets a nucleophile or base, you are choosing among four pathways. Reason through the same checklist each time: the substrate, the strength of the nucleophile or base, the solvent and the leaving group.

  • SN2: one step, with the nucleophile attacking from the side opposite the leaving group, so stereochemistry is inverted. The rate depends on both the substrate and the nucleophile. It is favoured by methyl and primary substrates, good nucleophiles and polar aprotic solvents such as DMSO or acetone. Tertiary substrates are too crowded.
  • SN1: two steps. The leaving group departs first, forming a carbocation, then the nucleophile attacks. The rate depends only on the substrate. It is favoured by tertiary substrates (and some secondary ones), weak nucleophiles and polar protic solvents such as water or alcohols. The carbocation is planar, so stereochemistry is lost, and rearrangements are possible.
  • E2: one step in which a strong base removes a hydrogen on the carbon next to the leaving group while the leaving group departs. It needs the hydrogen and the leaving group to be anti to each other. The more substituted alkene usually forms, unless a bulky base such as tert-butoxide is used, which tends to give the less substituted alkene.
  • E1: two steps through the same carbocation as SN1, then loss of a nearby hydrogen. It competes with SN1 and is favoured by heat and weak bases.

A quick rule: a strong, bulky base pushes toward E2; a strong nucleophile that is not very basic with a primary substrate pushes toward SN2; a tertiary substrate with a weak nucleophile in a polar protic solvent points to SN1 and E1.

Three worked examples

Example 1: 1-bromobutane with sodium cyanide in DMSO. The substrate is primary and the nucleophile (cyanide) is good, in a polar aprotic solvent. This is SN2. The arrow starts on the lone pair of the carbon in cyanide and points to the carbon bearing bromine. A second arrow goes from the carbon-bromine bond to bromine, which leaves as bromide. The product is pentanenitrile.

Example 2: tert-butyl bromide in warm ethanol. The substrate is tertiary and ethanol is a weak nucleophile and a polar protic solvent. This is SN1 and E1. Step one: an arrow from the carbon-bromine bond to bromine gives a tert-butyl carbocation and bromide. Step two: either ethanol attacks the carbocation with an oxygen lone pair, and loss of a proton gives the ether, or ethanol removes a neighbouring hydrogen to form 2-methylpropene.

Example 3: 2-bromo-2-methylbutane with sodium ethoxide. The substrate is tertiary and ethoxide is a strong base, so E2 wins. The ethoxide oxygen takes a hydrogen from a neighbouring carbon, the carbon-hydrogen bond becomes the new pi bond and the carbon-bromine bond breaks. The more substituted alkene, 2-methyl-2-butene, is the major product and 2-methyl-1-butene is minor.

What mistakes should you avoid?

  • Drawing arrows backwards. Arrows follow electrons, so they go from electron-rich to electron-poor, never the other way.
  • Starting arrows on atoms. The tail belongs on a lone pair or a bond, because that is where the electrons are.
  • Forgetting formal charges. If an oxygen gains a third bond, it picks up a positive charge. Count them after every step.
  • Using SN2 on a tertiary carbon. The backside is blocked, so look at SN1, E1 or E2 instead.
  • Ignoring the solvent and the base strength. The same substrate can give different products with different reagents.
  • Memorising instead of reasoning. A list of reactions fails on a problem you have not seen. The five steps work on any of them.

How should you practise?

Cover the answers to the textbook mechanisms, redraw each one and mark the nucleophile, electrophile and leaving group in colour. Then change one condition (the solvent, the base or the substrate) and predict what shifts. For wider chemistry support, read the chemistry homework help guide and whether online chemistry tutors are worth it. If you are wondering whether software can do this for you, see can AI chemistry solvers help with homework.

When you are stuck on one step, share your attempt and the exact step where it breaks, using our guide on how to ask a tutor a good homework question. On Our Easy Game, you post your question, tutors send offers, and you compare price, rating and timing before choosing. You can also check the subjects we cover.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if a carbon is an electrophile?

Look for a carbon bonded to a more electronegative atom, such as a halogen, oxygen or nitrogen, or a carbon in a carbonyl group. Those carbons carry a partial positive charge and attract nucleophiles.

Why do mechanisms use curved arrows?

Curved arrows track the movement of an electron pair. Reading them correctly lets you predict products, count charges and see why a step is reasonable.

Key takeaways

  • A mechanism is a record of electron movement, shown with curved arrows from source to sink.
  • Start every problem by labelling the nucleophile, the electrophile and the leaving group.
  • Update bonds, lone pairs and formal charges after every step.
  • Choose SN1, SN2, E1 or E2 by reasoning about the substrate, nucleophile or base, solvent and leaving group.
  • Practise by redrawing mechanisms from a blank page and changing one condition at a time.

Preparing for an exam? See how to study for finals with a tutor.

Don't Let Academic Struggles Hold You Back.

Transform your learning journey with our app’s powerful tools and expert guidance.

Private Tutors Online

Don't Let Academic Struggles Hold You Back.

Transform your learning journey with our app’s powerful tools and expert guidance.

DEVELOPED BY OEG OUTSOURCING

App Store Google Play